Our aim is to determine 1) how often the insecticides that Illinois farmers use can be expected to provide a positive return on investment and (2) the population density various insect pests must reach before control with an insecticide is economically justified. While published studies have examined the yield impacts of these tactics, our approach differs from published research in that (1) we will assess both seed treatments and foliar sprays (most studies have examined one or the other) and (2) we will thoroughly document insect population densities. This will allow us to identify the pest complexes most likely to negatively impact soybean production and therefore require control with an insecticide. We will work on both university research farms and in commercial farm fields, allowing us to compare tightly controlled experiments with multiple treatments to farmer-selected practices in a real-world setting and at a larger scale.