To make more informed pest management recommendations, farmers need to know (1) how often the controls they use can be expected to provide a positive return on investment and (2) the population density various insect pests must reach before a control is economically justified. We propose to address these knowledge gaps using simple field experiments placed both on University of Illinois research farms and on fields managed by cooperating farmers. We will apply pest controls that are commonly used as a preventative tactic by Illinois farmers, including insecticide seed treatments and foliar applications of pyrethroids targeting reproductive growth stages, and compare them with untreated plots. We will then thoroughly document insect population densities, yield, and other agronomic characteristics. By placing multiple trials throughout the state, we will observe both the frequency at which these inputs provide a positive return on investment and, when they do, the insect species most responsible for reducing soybean yields in Illinois.