Update:
OBJECTIVE 1: Soybean insecticide field efficacy evaluations
Erin Hodgson (Professor), Greg VanNostrand (Research Scientist), and Ashley Dean (Education Extension Specialist)
Soybean aphid. We established plots at the ISU Northwest Research Farm in 2023. In total, we evaluated 14 treatments with four insecticidal group/subgroups. The plots were initially colonized by soybean aphid in late June, and populations remained very low throughout the summer. There were a few other soybean pests present (e.g., spider mites, stink bugs, grasshoppers) but economic populations were not evident. Natural enemies, such as beetles, flies, lacewings, and wasps, were also present throughout the reproductive stages. The threshold was never reached, so plots were sprayed on 15 August when plants were at the R5 (beginning seed set) growth stage. Soybean aphid populations in the untreated control peaked in August with 60 aphids per plant. Since soybean aphid populations were well below the economic threshold, no yield losses were expected or observed. Average treatment yields ranged from 79.10 to 84.83 bushels per acre.
What does it mean for farmers: Soybean aphid is a sporadic pest, and populations are unpredictable
annually and field-to-field. Our recommendation for soybean aphid management in Iowa is to:
• Plant early if the field is in an area with persistent soybean aphid populations.
• Scout for soybean aphid, especially during R1–R5, and use a foliar insecticide if aphids exceed the economic threshold of 250 per plant.
• Use a product labeled for soybean aphid; there are some aphid populations that do not respond to pyrethroid insecticides anymore and considered resistant. If possible, select another insecticidal group for better yield protection.
• Evaluate foliar insecticide efficacy three days after application to ensure soybean aphid populations were sufficiently reduced.
• Understand that late-season accumulation of aphids (i.e., after R5) may not impact yield like it does in early reproductive growth; a foliar insecticide applied after seed set may not be an economically profitable choice.
Bean leaf beetle. We established plots at the ISU Johnson Research Farm in 2023. In total, we evaluated 31 treatments with at least six insecticidal group/subgroups. The plots were initially colonized by bean leaf beetle in June and populations remained active throughout the summer. There were a few other soybean pests present (e.g., spider mites, stink bugs, grasshoppers) but economic populations were not evident. Natural enemies, such as beetles, flies, lacewings, and wasps, were also present throughout the reproductive stages. We continued to sample through seed set where direct injury to pods was extensive in September. Most treatments had injury that exceeded 10%, which would be considered economically important.
What does it mean for farmers: Bean leaf beetle injury is increasing in intensity throughout Iowa. Direct injury to pods and seeds is. Our recommendation for bean leaf beetle aphid management in Iowa is to:
• Delay planting in fields with persistent populations, especially late-season injury.
• Continue to scout through seed set and use a foliar insecticide if pod injury exceeds 5-10%. Evaluate foliar insecticide efficacy three days after application to ensure soybean aphid populations were sufficiently reduced.
Soybean gall midge. We contributed to several regional research projects in 2023, including some commercial farm and ISU Research Farm locations. Summary of findings:
• Germplasm screening for host plant resistance remains the most hopeful suppression tactic. We screened 118 accession lines over three maturity groups (12 highly susceptible and 106 with suspected resistance from previous screenings) from University of Nebraska-Lincoln. Larvae are found in all the plots but at the suspected resistant lines have significantly reduced larval injury.
• Our lab identified six new counties with first detections (Hamilton, Hardin, Story, Marshall, Jasper, and Marion). They were located in the central part of Iowa, with now 49 counties now in total. See a current infestation map for the U.S. here: https://soybeangallmidge.org/soybean-gall-midge-distribution
OBJECTIVE 2: : Using RNAi to restore pyrethroid susceptibility among resistant soybean aphids
We have employed a PhD Student from the Federal University of Santa Maria as a hourly technician to conduct a series of laboratory-based experiments as part of this objective. From these experiments we have learned the optimal concentration for aphid mortality through a topical application of dsRNA. This experiment has revealed that when the dsRNA is delivered at this concentration with a sub-lethal dose of insecticide (lambda-cyhalothrin), ~90% of the soybean aphids died.
We are currently conducting an experiment to determine the optimal construction of dsRNA to kill all genotypes with mutations in their voltage-gated sodium channels. These mutations provide resistance to pyrethroids. We predict that a dsRNA probe that can silence multiple mutations will be the most efficacious. We anticipate this experiment will be completed in May.
Finally, we are preparing for an experiment that will employ the optimal dsRNA probe at a concentration that can kill 90% of the insecticide-resistant aphids when mixed with the insecticide. This experiment will be conducted in a spray chamber that mimics the application of insecticides in a field setting. Unlike previous experiments that involved applying dsRNA directly to aphids on small sections of soybean leaves, the spray chamber will apply treatments to aphid-infested plants. This experimetn will be completed by August.
We are unable to conduct any further experiments at this time as the cost of producing dsRNA is beyond what we had budgeted. A commercial source is available but is beyond our current resources to purchase.
OBJECTIVE 3: Extension communication strategies
Erin Hodgson (Professor) and Ashley Dean (Education Extension Specialist)
Summary: Our extension program is led by Dr. Erin Hodgson; however, many lab members also participate in programs throughout the year. Ashley Dean is also highly involved in presentations, publications, and social media. We are focused on delivering research-based information to a variety of clientele. Our group serves farmers, crop consultants, agricultural professionals and other university/extension personnel. Most of our programs are within the state of Iowa, but we travel throughout the Midwest to deliver content. Our program topics are mostly focused on promoting IPM tactics, such as host plant resistance, sampling, economic thresholds, crop rotation and buffer strips. We strive to provide sustainable recommendations so that farmers can reduce production costs but still protect yield. Although most of our extension is soybean insect-related, we are also involved with corn insect management, too.
Extension Outputs and Metrics for Soybean (January – April 2024):
Iowa Pest Alert Network: During our third year of this real-time messaging system, we have increased our subscribers to 371!
Meeting Proceedings: 1
Field Guides and Technical Reports: 4
Newsletter Articles, Blog Posts, etc.: 8
Lectures and Field Days: 6
Face-to-face contacts: 525
Erin Hodgson (@erinwhodgson) Twitter Followers: 3,331[167,000 impressions]
Ashley Dean (@ashleyn_dean) Twitter Followers: 457 [23,489 impressions]
Updated February 17, 2025:
During the summer of 2024 and fall, we have accomplished several activities supported by this funding. In this section, we briefly describe three activities, tracking insecticide resistant soybean aphids, developments towards the commercialization of a novel soybean aphid insecticide, and a list of the many presentations and extension documents that summarize research conducted through his project. Specifically, funding from the Iowa Soybean Association paid the salary of Ashley Dean, extension specialist who worked with the faculty on this great to deliver extension to farmers.
1. Tracking insecticide resistant soybean aphids:
To shorten a long story filled with a lot of data (described below), over 99% of the aphids captured in Iowa over a three year period had mutations that make them resistant to the most commonly used insecticides by soybean farmers. These aphids are present before insecticides are applied making those farmers using these insecticides at risk of yield loss in the future.
This level of resistance in a population is unlikely to be reversed. In other words, unless farmers switch to a different insecticide or use a different management strategy (like aphid-resistant soybeans), then they will not be able to prevent soybean aphid outbreaks in the future.
How did we come to this conclusion.
We collected aphids from commercial soybean fields in 2021, 2022, and 2023. We sequenced the DNA from key regions of these aphids to determine if they had mutations associated with insecticide resistance. We prioritized selecting fields in a region of Iowa with a high probability of experiencing a soybean aphid outbreak. Historically, the northern three tiers of counties in Iowa have experienced a higher frequency of economic outbreaks than rest of Iowa. Furthermore, soybean aphids with resistance to pyrethroids have been reported in this region. We identified commercial fields managed by farmers willing to give us access to survey aphids before and after an insecticide was applied. A pyrethroid was applied to 10 fields within North Central and Northwest Iowa according to the farmer’s practices, nine receiving lambda-cyhalothrin (warrior) and one bifenthrin.
The DNA sequencing data revealed almost all of the 1958 aphids collected had one or more mutations associated with pyrethroid resistance whether collected in a soybean field or suction trap. Nonsynonymous mutations were identified at four positions within the region of the soybean aphids genome were these mutations occur (DIISIV-S6 VGSC amplicon). They were an A-T transition at position 40 of the amplicon, causing a methionine to leucine shift (M918L), a G-A transition at position 42 (the last base of 918) causing a methionine to isoleucine shift (M918I), a T-A transition at position 61, causing a leucine to methionine shift (L925M), and a C-T transition at position 395, causing the kdr leucine to phenylalanine shift (L1014F). Differing zygosity and mutation combinations resulted in a total of 21 resistant variants identified from both field and suction trap collected aphids, in addition to the wild type which did not have any resistance mutations.
Within the field survey, we identified 18 genotypes (i.e. variants) with one or more mutations associated with pyrethroid resistance (See attached table). Aphids without a VGSC mutation (wild type, [WT]) represented < 0.1% of the aphids sequenced. The five most common variants represented ~90% of all aphids collected across all timepoints (Table 1). The L1014F heterozygote was the most frequently collected (variant 1, 36%), followed by the L925M + L1014F double heterozygote (variant 2, 25%), the M918I + L1014F double heterozygote (variant 3, 17%), the L1014F homozygote (variant 4, 9%). The same four variants represented 90 and 80% of the aphids sequenced collected before and after a pyrethroid application.
2. Commercialization of a novel pesticide:
Dr. O’Neal supervised a PhD candidate from the Federal University of Santa Maria, Bruna Wojahn, to conduct research in his lab at ISU throughout 2024, as part of a larger project to determine the mechanisms of mutations that make the soybean aphid resistant to pyrethroid insecticides. This work includes a collaboration with USDA scientist, Brad Coates and a MS student, Matthew Pfab (supported by ISA). This research revealed that specific strands of RNA can alter the phenotype of insecticide resistant aphids so that they are susceptible to insecticides. The team learned that combining the RNA with a pyrethroid can be a source of mortality to both resistant and susceptible populations of aphids. This discovery suggests a novel form of management that could counter resistance and allow farmers to use pyrethroids as opposed to more toxic and expensive active ingredients. The team produced sufficient evidence for a patent that was prepared and submitted by ISURF. Preliminary results were shared at the Entomological Society of America’s national meeting, resulting in a first-place award for Wojahn.
Patent application filed: ISURF #05432 R2. O'Neal, M.E., Coates, B.S., I. Valmorbida, J. Arnemann. Compositions And Methods For Restoring Susceptibility To Pyrethroid insecticides In Resistant Populations. On November 7 and December 15, 2024, provisional applications were filed under U.S. serial nos. 63/717,613 and 63/610,693. These filings are for the general technology that would address insecticide resistance by coupling RNAi that targets the resistant mutations, resulting in a return to the susceptible phenotype. Furthermore, this filing describes the a specific use of this technology for a key insect pest of soybeans that has developed resistance to the commonly used pyrethroids.
Since this patent filing, we have reached out to Greenlight Biosciences (https://www.greenlightbiosciences.com/), a leading company that has produced the first RNAi-based insecticide for use on crops in the US. This is a challenging process as Dr. O'Neal and Coates need to work with ISU and USDA to generate a non-disclosure agreement (NDA) with Greenlight Biosciences to discuss the potential of licensing this technology for the management of insecticide resistant soybean aphids. An NDA is currently (2/17/2025) is being reviewed by lawyers at Greenlight Biosciences. Once this review is completed, we can share results generated from this ISA funded project. As we wait on this review, we are also waiting on sharing the specific results from this larger project.
3. Extension activities:
Soybean-related extension entomology activities during this ISA-funded project (2021-2024):
Erin Hodgson and Ashley Dean
Awards: 4
National Association of County Agricultural Agents (NACAA) Publication Communications Award for Iowa 2024. North Central U.S. Regional Winner: Field Crop Insects, 2nd Edition (Sisson, Dean, Hodgson, and Rice)
National Association of County Agricultural Agents (NACAA) Bound Book/eBook Communications Award for Iowa 2024. National Finalist: Corn and Soybean Field Guide, 2nd Edition (Sisson, Mueller, Anderson, Dean, Hodgson, Licht, Mallarino, Munkvold, Rice, Robertson, and Tylka)
NCB-ESA Educational Project Award: Field Crop Insects Compendium, March 2024 (E. Hodgson, A. Dean, M. Rice, and A. Sisson)
NCB-ESA Educational Project Award: Camp Sketchapod, March 2024 (B. McCornack, E. Hodgson, C. Ly, J. Whisenant, and H. Shanovich)
National Association County Agricultural Agents, Search for Excellence Finalist for CropsTV Program, 2022 (ANR Crops Team)
Publications:
Peer-reviewed journal articles: 5
Cass, R., M. O’Neal, A. Toth, A. St. Clair, and E. Hodgson. 2022. Midwest attitudes about honey bees and pollinator-friendly practices: a survey of Iowan beekeepers, farmers, and landowners. Journal of Integrated Pest Management. DOI: 10.1093/jipm/pmac027.
Coyle, D. R., and E. W. Hodgson. 2022. Guiding the next generation of extension professionals: there’s a method to the madness. American Entomologist. DOI: 10.1093/ae/tmac036.
Huseth, A. S., R. L. Koch, D. Reisig, J. A. Davis, S. V. Paula-Moraes, and E. W. Hodgson. 2021. Current distribution and population persistence of five caterpillars in U.S. soybean. Journal of Integrated Pest Management. DOI: 10.1093/jipm/pmab004.
Hodgson, E. W., R. L. Koch, J. A. Davis, D. Reisig, and S. V. Paula-Moraes. 2021. Identification and biology of common caterpillars in U.S. soybean. Journal of Integrated Pest Management. DOI: 10.1093/jipm/pmab006.
McMechan, A. J., E. W. Hodgson, A. Varenhorst, T. Hunt, R. Wright, and B. Potter. 2021. Soybean gall midge (Diptera: Cecidomyiidae), a new species causing injury to soybean in the United States. Journal of Integrated Pest Management. DOI: 10.1093.jipm/pmab001.
Proceedings: 3
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. 2024. Resistance is a sticky situation for soybean aphid. In Field Notes: Iowa State University Crops Team (digital product).
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. 2022. Throwing the kitchen sink at soybean gall midge. In Field Notes: Iowa State University Crops Team (digital product).
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. 2022. Direct destruction: how to manage late-season pests. In Field Notes: Iowa State University Crops Team (digital product).
Field Guides: 3
Sisson, A, D. Mueller, A. Robertson, A. Dean, and E. W. Hodgson. 2023. Corn and soybean field guide, 236 pp. (2nd edition). Iowa State University Extension, Publication IPM 1.
Hodgson, E. W., A. Dean, M. Rice, and A. Sisson. 2023. Field crop insects, 80 pp. (2nd edition). Iowa State University Extension, Publication IPM 14.
Sisson, A. J., D. S. Mueller, S. P. Conley, C. K. Gerber, S. H. Graham, E. W. Hodgson, T. R. Leglieter, P. P. Price, K. J. Schaefer, E. J. Sikora, T. H. Wilkerson, and K. L. Wise. 2021. Crop scouting basics for corn and soybean. Crop Protection Network CPN 4007. DOI: 10.31274/cpn-20201214-0.
Newsletters/Blogs: 22
Hodgson, E., A. Dean, R. Vittetoe, and S. Gruss. “Fall armyworms making an appearance in 2024.” In ICM Blog. 20 August 2024.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Hungry hungry (grass)hoppers.” In ICM News. 29 July 2024.
Hodgson, E. “Got hoppers? Get sweeping!” In ICM Blog. 28 June 2024.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Japanese beetle adults emerging now.” In ICM News. 13 June 2024.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Soybean aphid egg hatch is finished.” In ICM News. 2 May 2024
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Warmest winter ever means low mortality for bean leaf beetle.” In ICM News. 17 April 2024
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Seedcorn maggots likely active throughout Iowa.” In ICM News. 12 April 2024
Hodgson, E., and A. Dean. “What does this warm winter mean for insects?” In ICM News. 12 March 2024.
Hodgson, E. “Blister beetles still active in Iowa.” In ICM Blog. 22 August 2023.
Hodgson, E., and A. Dean. “Speed Scout this year for soybean aphid.” In ICM News. 7 August 2023.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Japanese beetles now emerging.” In ICM News. 16 June 2023.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Soybean gall midge adults now emerging.” In ICM News. 8 June 2023.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Soybean aphid egg hatch is complete.” In ICM News. 4 May 2023.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Variable overwintering success for bean leaf beetles this year.” In ICM News. 26 April 2023.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Japanese beetle adult emergence begins in southern Iowa.” In ICM News. 21 June 2022.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Soybean gall midge adult emergence begins.” In ICM Encyclopedia Article. 17 June 2022.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Start scouting for stalk borers in southern Iowa.” In ICM Encyclopedia Article. 10 June 2022.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Soybean aphid egg hatch nearly complete.” In ICM Encyclopedia Article. 11 May 2022.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Stalk borer.” In ICM Encyclopedia Article. 5 May 2022.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Growing degree days for insect pests.” In ICM Encyclopedia Article. 3 May 2022.
Dean, A., and E. Hodgson. “Another tough winter for bean leaf beetle.” In ICM News. 19 April 2022.
Dean, A., E. Hodgson, and C. Pilcher. “Updates on chlorpyrifos uses in 2022. In ICM News. 10 March 2022.
Invited Presentations:
Regional: 4
Hodgson, E. W. Current insect pest management challenges in Iowa. United Kingdom Chief Plant Health Officer Meeting. Ames, IA [8 people] 31 October 2024
Hodgson, E. W. Updates on pest management strategies for field crop pests. Certified Entomologists of Mid-America Summer Business Meeting, Ames, IA [12 people] 12 August 2023
Hodgson, E. W. What happens when the easy button fails: insect management outlook. University of Missouri Crop Management Conference, Columbia, MO [175 people] 15 December 2022
Hodgson, E. W. Let’s get real about soybean insecticides: what’s in and works. Crop Pest Management Short Course, Minneapolis, MN [2 sessions; 225 people] 8 December 2021
Statewide: 29
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Resistance is a sticky situation for soybean aphid. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Crop Advantage Series Workshops.
- Storm Lake, IA. [12 people] 2 January 2025
- Sioux Center, IA. [7 people] 7 January 2025
- Burlington, IA. [2 people] 9 January 2025
- Mason City, IA. [85 people] 10 January 2025
- Waterloo, IA. [15 people] 16 January 2025
- Okoboji, IA. [82 people] 14 January 2025
- Davenport, IA. [8 people] 17 January 2025
- Le Mars, IA. [35 people] 28 January 2025
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Resistance is a sticky situation for soybean aphid. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Integrated Crop Management Annual Conference, Altoona, IA. [2 sessions; 225 people] 12 December 2024
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Resistance is a sticky situation for soybean aphid. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Crop Clinic for Worth and Cerro Gordo Counties, Manly, IA. [65 people] 6 December 2024
Hodgson, E. W. Insects, weeds, and plant disease: implications of recent warm winters and climate change for soil health, yields, and land valuation. 96th Annual Soil Management and Land Valuation Conference, Ames, IA. [175 people] 15 May 2024
Hodgson, E. Soybean gall midge research updates. Regional field day, ENREEC, University of Nebraska-Lincoln, Mead, NE. [4 sessions; 130 people] 25-26 July 2023
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Throwing the kitchen sink at soybean gall midge. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Crop Advantage Series Workshops.
- Storm Lake, IA. [11 people] 4 January 2023
- Webster City, IA. [2 sessions; 40 people] 11 January 2023
- Ankeny, IA. [2 sessions; 30 people] 17 January 2023
- Denison, IA. [15 people] 26 January 2023
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Direct destruction: how to manage late-season pests. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Crop Advantage Series Workshops.
- Burlington, IA. [25 people] 5 January 2023
- Atlantic, IA. [66 people] 19 January 2023
- Davenport, IA. [25 people] 20 January 2023
- Le Mars, IA. [25 people] 20 January 2023
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Throwing the kitchen sink at soybean gall midge. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Ag Chem Dealer Update.
- Nevada, IA. [20 people] 13 December 2022
- Crawfordsville, IA. [35 people] 14 December 2022
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Direct destruction: how to manage late-season pests. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Integrated Crop Management Annual Conference, Ames, IA. [2 sessions; 175 people] 30 November 2022
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Throwing the kitchen sink at soybean gall midge. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Integrated Crop Management Annual Conference, Ames, IA. [2 sessions; 190 people] 1 December 2022
Dean, A., and E. W. Hodgson. Throwing the kitchen sink at soybean gall midge. Iowa Advanced Agronomy Day, Growmark, Ames, IA [35 people] 21 November 2022
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Insect identification, scouting and recognizing injury. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Crop Scout School, Cedar Rapids, IA. [3 sessions, 39 people] 19 May 2022
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Soybean gall midge and fall armyworm management. 2022 Iowa State University Extension and Outreach Crop Advantage Series Workshops.
- Sheldon, IA. [8 people] 6 January 2022
- Storm Lake. IA. [10 people] 7 January 2022
- Le Mars, IA. [13 people] 26 January 2022
Virtual: 9
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Soybean aphid resistance sucks. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach CropsTV, January - March 2025
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Another boring pest: Dectes stem borer management. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach CropsTV, January - March 2024
Hodgson, E. W. No “easy button” for sustainable insect management. PSEP Program, Iowa State University. January - December 2024.
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Direct destruction: how to manage late-season pests. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach CropsTV, January - March 2023
Hodgson, E. W., and A. Dean. Throwing the kitchen sink at soybean gall midge. Iowa State University Extension and Outreach CropsTV, January - March 2023
Hodgson, E. W., B. Kolbe, and J. McMechan. Can pre-season tactics help with soybean gall midge management? Regional webinar for soybean gall midge, Virtual Delivery. [230 live views] 27 February 2023
Dean, A., and E. W. Hodgson. Tolerances revoked for chlorpyrifos: what are some other options? Loveland/Nutrien Regional Meeting Virtual Delivery, 25 March 2022
Hodgson, E. W., B. Kolbe, and J. McMechan. Using tillage to reduce overwintering soybean gall midge. Soybean gall midge discussion series, Virtual Delivery. 22 February 2022
Hodgson, E. W., and J. McMechan. Soybean gall midge ID, distribution, scouting tips, and injury score. Soybean gall midge discussion series, Virtual Delivery. 15 February 2022
View uploaded report 