2024
Multiple herbicide resistance in Palmer amaranth and use of gene editing for its management
Contributor/Checkoff:
Category:
Sustainable Production
Keywords:
AgricultureCrop protectionHerbicide
Lead Principal Investigator:
Mithila Jugulam, Kansas State University
Co-Principal Investigators:
Project Code:
2466
Contributing Organization (Checkoff):
Leveraged Funding (Non-Checkoff):
NA
Institution Funded:
Brief Project Summary:
Development of resistance to multiple herbicides in Palmer amaranth and other weeds has been increasing rapidly. Palmer amaranth has been shown to be resistant to six herbicide modes of action groups and can metabolize five herbicide groups without any changes in target site. Metabolic resistance can predispose weeds to evolve resistance to other groups of herbicides. In this project, researchers apply genetic and molecular methods to identify the basis for development of metabolic resistance to multiple herbicides in Palmer amaranth using RNA-sequencing technique followed by bioinformatics analyses. Outcomes will help in designing more sustainable strategies for weed management.
Key Beneficiaries:
#agronomists, #applicators, #breeders, #farmers, #growers, #researchers
Unique Keywords:
#breeding and genetics, #cytochrome p450 genes, #herbicide resistance, #herbicides, #weed control, #weed management, #weeds
Information And Results
Project Summary

Development of resistance to multiple herbicides in Palmer amaranth and other major weeds of Midwestern US has been increasing rapidly, which is a serious threat for sustainable soybean production. In some scenarios growers are losing herbicide options to manage this weed. We have identified a Palmer amaranth population resistant to 6 herbicide modes of action groups. Importantly, this population can metabolize 5 herbicides group without any changes in herbicide target site. There are two major enzyme families involved in metabolism of herbicides, Cytochrome P450 and Glutathione S-transference (GST). These enzymes are important in providing selectivity for many of the herbicides used in crops. Metabolic resistance in weed can predispose them to evolve resistance to other groups of herbicides as well, which will be a serious problem for the management. In this project we intend to apply genetic and molecular methods to identify the basis for the development of metabolic resistance to multiple herbicides in Palmer amaranth. We will identify the specific enzymes involved in herbicide metabolism using RNA-sequencing technique followed by bioinformatics analyses. The outcome of this research will help in designing more sustainable strategies for weed management

Project Objectives

Overall objective:
1. Investigate common mechanism(s) that can predispose Palmer amaranth to develop multiple herbicide resistance
Sub-objectives:
1a. Understand the role of cytochrome P450 enzymes (CYP) in imparting metabolic resistance to Group 2, 4, 14 and 27 herbicides in Palmer amaranth.
1b. Understand the role of glutathione-S-transferases (GST) in imparting metabolic resistance to Group 5 and other herbicides.

Project Deliverables

We will identify the specific metabolic enzymes i.e., cytochrome P450 or glutathione S transferases involved in the metabolism of multiple herbicides. Additionally, the RNA-sequencing data will be available for functional validation and also assess the role of other genes if any involved in herbicide resistance compared to susceptible plants.
We will also train a graduate student in weed genomics area, which is a novel field in weed science and provide hands on experience in bioinformatics.

Progress Of Work

Updated January 15, 2024:
As reported in the previous progress report, upon transcriptome analyses of the multiple
herbicide-resistant Palmer amaranth resistant and susceptible samples, we identified 97
differentially expressed genes in the resistant plants when compared to susceptible without any
treatment. This data is further analyzed to identify any of these differentially expressed genes
belonging to cytochrome P450 or glutathione-s-transferase enzyme family. These two enzyme
families are known metabolize multiple herbicides in plans. The paired end reads generated from
RNA seq data, were generated were mapped to the Palmer amaranth transcriptome using HISAT.
Differential gene expression analysis conducted using DEseq2, revealed up-regulation or down
regulation of several genes as shown in Table 1 following treatments with chlorsulfuron,
atrazine, mesotrione and 2,4-D, in the resistant plants compared to susceptible plants. Overall,
more genes were differentially expressed upon chlorsulfuron, and atrazine treatment compared to
2,4-D and mesotrione. Additionally, two genes, CYP72A218 and CYP82D47 were found to be
constitutively upregulated across all treatments. These two genes are known to be involved in
phase-I metabolism of herbicides. Work is in progress to validate the expression levels of the two
CYP genes in the resistant and susceptible Palmer amaranth plants via real time-quantitative
PCR analysis. Identification and confirmation of genes involved in multiple herbicide
metabolism in this Palmer amaranth will be valuable to demonstrate that metabolic resistance
predisposes weed populations to evolve resistance to other herbicides without selection.

View uploaded report PDF file

Final Project Results

Updated August 13, 2024:
A Palmer amaranth population with resistance to six herbicides (6-way) was identified in KS. This Palmer amaranth population was collected from a 45-year old tillage study maintained in continuous sorghum. A variety of herbicides were used in the research trial, with 2,4-D and atrazine used most frequently. However, when plants from this population were studied in the greenhouse, they survived applications of group 2 herbicides Glean (chlorsulfuron), Harmony (thifensulfuron), Beyond (imazamox), Pursuit (imazethapyr); group 14 herbicides Cobra (lactofen) and Flexstar (fomesafen); the group 27 herbicides Callisto (mesotrione) and Laudis (tembotrione), metribuzin (group 5); and glyphosate (group 9); as well as atrazine (group 5) and 2,4-D (group 4). The only herbicides in the study that provided 100% control were Liberty (glufosinate) and Gramoxone (paraquat). Such multiple herbicide resistant Palmer amaranth populations are spreading rapidly posing a serious threat for sustainable soybean production. In some scenarios growers are losing herbicide options to manage this weed. Although use of herbicides still offers an effective weed management strategy, such strategy needs to be complemented with long term sustainable biological-based strategies. The 6-way resistant Palmer amaranth converts the herbicides to inactive forms before the plant can be killed, often due to the activity of two groups of enzymes: cytochrome P450s (P450) and glutathione S-transfersases (GSTs). These enzymes provide selectivity to many of the herbicides used in crops. We hypothesized that the activity of these enzymes may be elevated in the 6-way resistant Palmer amaranth. In Year-1 of this project we proposed genetic and molecular methods to assess the activity of herbicide degrading enzymes in this Palmer amaranth. Year-2 of this project is primarily focused on characterization of the herbicide degrading enzymes including P450 or GST.
Overall objective:
1. Investigate common mechanism(s) that can predispose Palmer amaranth to develop multiple herbicide resistance
Sub-objectives:
1a. Understand the role of cytochrome P450 enzymes (CYP) in imparting metabolic resistance to Group 2, 4, 14 and 27 herbicides in Palmer amaranth.
1b. Understand the role of glutathione-S-transferases (GST) in imparting metabolic resistance to Group 5 and other herbicides.

Upon transcriptome analyses of the multiple herbicide-resistant Palmer amaranth resistant and susceptible samples, we identified 97 differentially expressed genes in the resistant plants when compared to susceptible without any treatment. This data is further analyzed to identify any of these differentially expressed genes belonging to cytochrome P450 or glutathione-s-transferase enzyme family. These two enzyme families are known metabolize multiple herbicides in plans. The paired end reads generated from RNA seq data, were generated were mapped to the Palmer amaranth transcriptome using HISAT. The quality of the raw RNA-Seq data was assessed using FASTQC (https://www.bioinformatics.babraham.ac.uk/projects/fastqc/) and adaptor sequences were trimmed using Trimmomatic. Trimmed reads were mapped again to Amaranthus palmeri reference transcriptome using STAR (https://github.com/alexdobin/STAR) and the number of mapped reads for each contig were counted using EBSeq (https://doi.org/10.1093/bioinformatics/btt087). A pairwise differential gene expression analysis was performed using DEseq2 package in R studio and probable gene function for differentially expressed genes were annotated. Following alignment and differential expression with DESeq2, Filtering parameters were for the adjusted p-value = < 0.05 and log2 fold change > 2.0 . We identified 130 differentially expressed genes in the resistant plants when compared to susceptible without any treatment. Additionally, 131, 152, 530, 414, and 689 genes were differentially expressed when resistant plants were compared to susceptible plants upon 2,4-D, mesotrione, arazine, chlorsulfuron and lactofen treatment. When the nontreated comparison were further studied two genes CYP72A219 and CYP704B1 were found to be consecutively overexpressed in the resistant plants. RT-qPCR results confirmed the overexpression of CYP72A219 and CYP704B1 genes by 6.6-7.1 and 16.7-18.8 folds respectively. These results validate our hypothesis that certain P450 genes can contribute to multiple herbicide resistance in Palmer amaranth. Current efforts are underway to conduct Arabidopsis transformation to develop transgenics that can overexpress the gene CYP72A219 for in planta confirmation of involvement of this gene in herbicide metabolism.
The outcome of this research will demonstrate the greatest threat associated with multiple resistance in weeds and importantly, that a single resistance mechanism can provide resistance to multiple herbicide groups. While mixing and rotation herbicides with multiple, effective modes of action can slow the evolution of resistance, cross-resistance associated with multiple resistance greatly reduces the effectiveness of this strategy. Minimizing the weed seed bank and adopting alternative management strategies is essential to protect the value of existing and future herbicides.

View uploaded report PDF file

Overall, we have validated the hypothesis that the cytochrome P450 enzymes known to metabolize multiple herbicides are involved in the evolution of multiple herbicide resistance in Palmer amaranth. Our molecular analyses confirms the increased expression of CYP72A219 and CYP704B1 genes in herbicide metabolism. These results suggest that the weed populations with increased activity of enzymes involved in herbicide metabolism will predispose such populations to evolve resistance to new herbicides or those that are not used previously.

Benefit To Soybean Farmers

We will identify the specific metabolic enzymes i.e., cytochrome P450 or glutathione S transferases involved in the metabolism of multiple herbicides. Additionally, the RNA-sequencing data will be available for functional validation and also assess the role of other genes if any involved in herbicide resistance compared to susceptible plants.
We will also train a graduate student in weed genomics area, which is a novel field in weed science and provide hands on experience in bioinformatics.

The United Soybean Research Retention policy will display final reports with the project once completed but working files will be purged after three years. And financial information after seven years. All pertinent information is in the final report or if you want more information, please contact the project lead at your state soybean organization or principal investigator listed on the project.