2022
Breeding of Glyphosate-Resistant Soybean Cultivars
Contributor/Checkoff:
Category:
Sustainable Production
Keywords:
GeneticsGenomics
Lead Principal Investigator:
Carrie Miranda, North Dakota State University
Co-Principal Investigators:
Project Code:
QSSB
Contributing Organization (Checkoff):
Institution Funded:
Brief Project Summary:
This project allows North Dakota State University to continue the process of developing glyphosate-resistant soybean cultivars. There are glyphosate-resistant experimental soybean lines in the NDSU breeding program being tested in a range of maturities from 1.0 to a 00.4, and properly adapted throughout the state. The project will significantly reduce seed costs to soybean growers. Cultivars developed at NDSU are not patented, allowing farmers to save their own seed for planting the following year. The cost savings for growers that purchase glyphosate-resistant cultivars developed by NDSU will occur in subsequent years after the initial purchase.
Key Beneficiaries:
#agronomists, #farmers, #soybean breeders
Unique Keywords:
#breeding, #breeding & genetics, #genetics, #herbicide resistance, #herbicides, #soybean varieties
Information And Results
Project Summary

The grant would enable NDSU to continue the process of developing glyphosate-resistant soybean cultivars. There are glyphosate-resistant experimental lines in the NDSU breeding program that are being tested in a range of maturity that varies from a 1.0 to a 00.4 maturity, and properly adapted throughout the entirety of North Dakota. New experimental lines are developed each year. This project will significantly reduce seed costs to soybean growers. NDSU has a very large breeding program devoted to development of glyphosate-resistant cultivars and will continue to expand this year. Monsanto has stated that starting in 2015 growers will be able to save their own seed for planting the following year. However, the private company cultivars are also protected under a Variety Patent. Cultivars developed at NDSU are not patented. The cost savings for growers that purchase glyphosate-resistant cultivars developed by NDSU will occur the second and subsequent years after the initial purchase of the seed. The seed of new experimental lines will be increased in Chile, S.A. each winter to speed the development and release.

Project Objectives

The objective is to continue the process of developing glyphosate-resistant experimental lines with a goal of releasing additional cultivars of varying maturities that are developed by NDSU.

Project Deliverables

The first glyphosate-resistant cultivar (ND17009GT) was released in January of 2017. ND17009GTis a 00.9 maturity, glyphosate-resistant variety with high yield, excellent phytophthora root rot resistance that is moderately tolerant to IDC. ND18008GT is a 00.7 maturity, glyphosate-resistant NDSU variety that was released in January of 2018. ND18008GT is resistant to soybean aphid, has an excellent gene for phytophthora root rot resistance, good IDC tolerance and lodging resistance as well as yield that is equal to a private-company RR2 variety. Certified seed of ND17009GT was available to growers in the spring of 2018. Commercial quantities of ND18008GT should be available to growers in the spring of 2019. The NDSU Soybean Breeding program has a past history of producing new cultivars that are very competitive with private company products. ND15-22873GT is a glyphosate-resistant experimental line of 0.7 relative maturity that has been approved for pre-release and will be considered for release as a named cultivar in January of 2020.

Progress Of Work

Updated December 1, 2021:
Breeding of Glyphosate-Resistant Soybean Cultivars (2021)- Miranda

Objectives of the research: The objective is to continue the process of developing glyphosate-resistant experimental lines with a goal of releasing additional cultivars of varying maturities that are developed by NDSU.

Completed work: The glyphosate resistant program was two/thirds of the NDSU soybean program in 2021. Obe promising early maturity line is being increased at the winter nursery in Chile. Testing for possible release is being done for the first GT SCN resistant variety. In addition, seventy-five new populations that have the glyphosate resistant gene were created that may eventually become new high yielding lines that also have other useful traits such as SCN and IDC resistance. Soybean sudden death resistance has also been added to the program this year. The goal is to stack this resistance gene with the SCN resistance gene to ensure protection for ND farmers. Those are currently being advanced in the winter nursery along with three hundred and four lines that will be grown as fourth generation plants in 2022. In 2024, lines selected from that experiment will be entered into the first year of yield tests. Several hundred lines glyphosate resistant lines were selected for the first year of yield testing in 2021 which also exhibit other promising traits such a SCN and IDC tolerance. In 2021, the focus of the NDSU program will shifted to glyphosate tolerant lines. Data collected in the 2021 harvest and is currently being analyzed.

Preliminary results: Additional analysis is ongoing to determine which lines will continue testing in 2022. 75 new populations were created which are being grown in Chile this winter. In four years, these lines will begin yield testing.

Work to be completed: Data harvested in 2021 is currently being analyzed for selections of promising lines. Advanced lines will be yield tested throughout the state in 2022 to ensure high yield and correct adaptation to specific regions of the state and ensure superior agronomic traits i.e. lodging resistance. Increased glyphosate resistant lines will continue to be evaluated for yield and agronomic performance, in addition to being cleaned of contaminating lines while continuously being increased. They will also be analyzed for disease resistance with collaborating partners. At the end of 2022, line(s) that are considered superior and have enough quantity of seed will be entered into pre release.

Final Project Results

Updated August 19, 2022:
July 1, 2021 – June 30, 2022
Annual Report: Breeding of Glyphosate-Resistant Soybean Cultivars
Principal Investigator: Dr. Carrie Miranda, Department of Plant Sciences, North Dakota State University – Cooperating Scientists: Dr. Berlin Nelson, Department of Plant Pathology, North Dakota State University; Dr. Guiping Yan, Department of Plant Pathology, North Dakota State University

Growers would like to purchase glyphosate-resistant soybean varieties that are high-yielding, are lodging and IDC-tolerant, and have good disease and pest resistance and be able to save their own seed for the next crop year. Soybean varieties are protected by a patent on the glyphosate-resistant gene (construct) and often protected by a second patent on the variety. Monsanto has provided a website to explain these issues (http://www.soybeans.com/patent.aspx). Fortunately, the RoundUp Ready 1 glyphosate resistant gene has come off patent and also does not require regulation for use. By utilizing this herbicide resistance mechanism, North Dakota farmers will have access to unlicensed, high yielding, glyphosate tolerant soybean varieties through North Dakota State University. The purpose of this research is to provide superior glyphosate-resistant varieties that have been developed by the North Dakota State University soybean breeding program. The research objective is to continue to produce superior soybean varieties suitable for North Dakota with glyphosate tolerance.
To ensure these successes, new experimental lines need to be initiated every year. Crosses to develop Roundup Ready (RR1) experimental lines were begun in the summer of 2010 and new crosses have been made every summer since then, including 2021. Crossing between varieties is the first step to developing new experimental lines. Each summer that crosses have been developed, an effort has been made to develop populations with phytophthora root rot resistance and SCN resistance by using at least one parent that is resistant to one or both of these pathogens or pests.

In 2021, 53 new crosses between glyphosate resistant soybean varieties and either high yielding, SCN resistant, P. sojae resistant varieties (or a combination of those traits) were attempted resulting in 304 F1 seeds that were sent to the winter nursery in Chile for advancement.

In addition in 2021, 3401 glyphosate-resistant plant-rows (F5) were planted and 1439 were selected for first year yield testing in 2022. This large number of lines selected for first year yield testing signifies a shift in priority for the North Dakota soybean breeding program. Due to the success of this project for so many years, the glyphostate resistant breeding project will now become the main priority for breeding due to the successful incorporation of not only the herbicide resistance but also high yield and several disease resistant traits.
From yield testing conducted in 2021, 2 lines were selected for seed increase in the winter nursery in Chile. Both of these lines were entered for 2021 prerelease and are awaiting approval pending further data. This line is MG 00.6, which is useful for northern North Dakota and Canada. The other line is MG 0.2 and shows moderate resistance to SCN. This would be the first glyphosate tolerant and SCN resistant line that the NDSU breeding program releases.

Finally, for all lines in advanced yielding testing, SCN resistance testing was conducted in 2021 by Guiping Yan of North Dakota State University. This is new step forward for the NDSU soybean breeding program in controlling the devastation that SCN can cause to farmers. Berlin Nelson tested all lines entered into our third year advanced yield tests and found the vast majority are resistant to Race 4 of Phytophthora and the remainder are resistant to Race 3. This is thanks to the fastidiousness in breeding and testing that was conducted by Ted Helms and Berlin Nelson.

The benefit of this research to the North Dakota soybean industry would be that growers can save input costs because they would be able to save their own seed for replanting the following year. At present, farmers must purchase expensive new seed each year. According to Monsanto, when the patent is no longer viable for the Roundup Ready One technology, growers are supposed to be able to save their own seed and plant it without fines or penalty.

View uploaded report Word file

View uploaded report 2 Word file

July 1, 2021 – June 30, 2022
Final Project Results: Breeding of Glyphosate-Resistant Soybean Cultivars
Principal Investigator: Dr. Carrie Miranda, Department of Plant Sciences, North Dakota State University – Cooperating Scientists: Dr. Berlin Nelson, Department of Plant Pathology, North Dakota State University; Dr. Guiping Yan, Department of Plant Pathology, North Dakota State University

This project has enabled NDSU to continue the process of developing glyphosate-resistant soybean cultivars. There are glyphosate-resistant experimental lines in the NDSU breeding program that are being tested in a range of maturity that varies from a 1.0 to a 00.4 maturity, and properly adapted throughout the entirety of North Dakota. New experimental lines are developed each year including in 2021. This project has significantly reduced seed costs to soybean growers. Cultivars with glyphosate resistance developed at NDSU are not patented. The cost savings for growers that purchase glyphosate-resistant cultivars developed by NDSU will occur the second and subsequent years after the initial purchase of the seed. The seed of new experimental lines has been increased in Chile, S.A. each winter to speed the development and release.
This project has been successful with the first glyphosate tolerant variety (ND17009GT) released in 2017 and two new varieties were successfully released in 2020. 21ND08GT73 is a MG 0.8 and the first later maturing GT line released by the NDSU program. This line allows a more growers in North Dakota access to the cost effective NDSU GT lines. 21ND008GT20 is a MG 00.8 variety and considered an improvement on ND17009GT due to its increase IDC tolerance.
A successful breeding pipeline continually has promising materials moving through it. In addition to the two variety releases, prereleases are continually entered. There is a MG 00.6 experimental line suggested for prerelease that requires additional data.
In addition there is also a MG 0.2 experimental line suggested for prerelease that also has moderate SCN resistance that was validated by Guiping Yan. Phytophthora resistance for all these lines and other in advanced yield trials was validated by Berlin Nelson.



Benefit To Soybean Farmers

The intent is that growers will be able to reduce their input costs by purchasing high-yielding, very competitive, glyphosate-resistant cultivars developed at NDSU. Monsanto has stated that starting in 2015 growers will be able to save their own seed for planting the following year. However, the private company cultivars are also protected under a Variety Patent. Varieties developed at NDSU are not patented. Currently, two glyphosate-resistant varieties that were developed by NDSU are available to soybean growers.

The United Soybean Research Retention policy will display final reports with the project once completed but working files will be purged after three years. And financial information after seven years. All pertinent information is in the final report or if you want more information, please contact the project lead at your state soybean organization or principal investigator listed on the project.